Info!! Cyclically Adaptive Trading (Cat)

The recent post highlighted the challenge of short-term trading returns over the past times twelvemonth and, indeed, since 2009.  In this post, I volition sketch how I am addressing those challenges inward my ain trading.

When traders cite to the hard trading environment, they oft brand reference to "choppy" or "noisy" markets.  Usually their adjacent sentences lament the "algos" together with their comport on upon markets.  I detect these to endure expressions of frustration, non constructive formulations of trading challenges.  Invariably, those lamenting choppy markets dominated past times algos that "manipulate" markets engage inward their venting--and therefore become dorsum to trading every bit they've ever traded...and continue to lose money.  

A telephone substitution to agreement the recent hapless returns of curt term traders is to appreciate that these traders don't exactly lack an edge; they conduct maintain a negative edge.  What they are doing, which largely falls into the category of trend/momentum trading, is systematically non working over time.  Waiting for high Sharpe trends to provide to markets has non been a audio describe of piece of job concern model.  But peradventure nosotros tin merchandise inward a agency that benefits from anti-trending/mean reversion every bit good every bit momentum.

In coming months, I volition endure rolling out an approach that I cite to every bit Cyclically Adaptive Trading (CAT).  The meat stance behind the strategy is that all markets comprise linear, directional elements (trends) together with cyclical elements.  On a given fourth dimension frame, a "noisy" or "choppy" surround is simply i inward which the cyclical aspects of marketplace behaviour dominate the linear ones.  Note that whatever marketplace cycle itself has linear (rising together with falling) components together with make saltation ones (topping together with bottoming).  Very often, what is a tendency on i fourth dimension scale is a percentage of a longer-term cycle.  The interaction of cycles over multiple fourth dimension frames creates challenging irregularities, every bit markets switch betwixt mean-reverting together with trending phases.

The stance of CAT is that you lot trade the market's personality, non your own.  Instead of trading the fourth dimension frame together with style you lot travel on to prefer, you lot merchandise the cycles setting upward inward markets.  Because in that location are multiple cycles at travel at whatever i fourth dimension together with because the dynamics of the electrical flow cycles are influenced past times the activity of prior cycles, we tin seat dominant cycles inward existent fourth dimension together with adjust trading parameters to those.  This is the adaptive chemical element inward cyclically adaptive trading.  The argue therefore many traders are failing is that they lock themselves into preferred fourth dimension frames together with trading styles.  An adaptive approach is i that trades momentum/trend when nosotros are inward the rising together with falling phases of cycles together with i that trades inward a value/mean-reverting style when nosotros are inward the topping together with bottoming phases.  We merchandise longer-term when longer-term cycles dominate together with shorter-term when nosotros run into those "choppier" conditions.  Trading i fourth dimension frame inward i style systematically fails over fourth dimension inward markets possessing potent cyclical elements.

(A corollary is that, to the flat you lot seat yourself, say, every bit a directional trader or a short-term trader, you lot are likely losing money.  Someone who limits themselves to trading i facet of marketplace cycles is similar a baseball game hitter who specializes inward hitting fast balls.  If you lot larn plenty of those guys on a team, it doesn't conduct maintain the opposition long to set breaking ball together with off-speed pitchers on the mound.)

A 2nd major stance behind CAT is that cycles are self organizing:  recent cycles comport on the creation of novel cycles which interact to generate other, unlike cycles.  There is no unmarried periodicity to cycles that tin endure traded mechanically and, indeed, I conduct maintain doubts that cycles fifty-fifty be inward chronological time.  Markets displace inward event units of cost motility together with volume: every bit participants travel inward together with larn out markets, they comport on cycles inward ways that comport on futurity cost behavior.  In other words, cycles are a component subdivision of the behaviour of marketplace participants, non a component subdivision of the passage of fourth dimension on a clock. Our project every bit traders is to adapt to the market's clock together with trade inward marketplace time, non our time.

The trading I am rolling out is based upon an advance I've made inward tracking the self-organization of cycles over multiple effect fourth dimension horizons.

Some sources of insight into marketplace cycles tin endure flora inward the early on technical industrial plant of George Lindsay together with Terry Laundry.  Important quantitative perspectives together with tools conduct maintain been offered past times John Ehlers, who introduced the notion of adapting technical trading systems to dominant cycle periods.  Relevant posts seem below, together with I volition endure posting to a greater extent than every bit I formally curl this out inward my trading.

Further Reading:

The Dynamics of Market Cycles

Trading Market Cycles 

A Unique Measure of Market Cycles

Using Cycles to Trade Trends 

Reading Market Cycles

Trading Techniques

.

Info!! The Psychology Of Trading Without The Ego

A surprising sum of piteous trading comes from trading our egos, non from genuinely trading markets.

When nosotros focus on predicting marketplace moves together with trading our views alongside conviction, trading speedily becomes a game of the ego.

When nosotros declare that nosotros convey a certainly trading "style" together with nosotros hold back for marketplace weather condition to conform our style, trading becomes ego-based.

When nosotros obsessively sentry screens together with focus on each displace of P/L, trading turns into an ego game.

We tin purpose every technique nether the Sun to instill champaign of written report together with overcome emotions, but if nosotros pursue trading through the ego, nosotros volition survive vulnerable.

An analogy I've used inward my books is the expert dancer on a trip the low-cal fantastic floor.  The expert dancer doesn't merely trip the low-cal fantastic his or her manner regardless of the music playing.  The expert dancer does non laid out dancing ahead of the music, anticipating the side past times side tune.  The expert dancer waits for the music to start, catches the crunch together with tone, together with dances accordingly.

In my recent trading, I've been taking ego out of the picture.  I examine a stable lookback menstruation inward the recent marketplace together with position 2 things:

1)  Has at that topographic point been a dominant tendency over that period?
2)  Have at that topographic point been 1 or to a greater extent than dominant cycles over that period?

If I tin divulge no clear tendency or cycles, I don't trade.

If at that topographic point is no trend, but a dominant cycle, I merchandise the hypothesis that this cycle volition conk along into the immediate futurity unless I run across clear changes inward marketplace volume, volatility, intelligence events, etc.  That has me buying prospective cycle lows together with selling highs.  In that regime, I aspect similar a value trader.

If at that topographic point is a distinct trend, but no clear cycle, I purpose the laid out pullbacks/bounces inward the NYSE TICK to displace into together with ride the trend, over again unless I run across clear bear witness of changes inward the market's trading.  In that regime, I aspect similar a momentum investor.

If at that topographic point is a distinct tendency *and* 1 or to a greater extent than dominant cycles, together with therefore I am using the cycles to guide entries together with exits inward the direction of the trend.  In that regime, my execution is counter-trend (value), but the overall thought is trend-based (momentum).

We endure when nosotros hold back markets to merchandise the agency *we* desire them to trade.  There are valuable tools that help us position cycles together with trends.  That enables us to bask the market's trip the low-cal fantastic music--and net income from it.

Further Reading:

Trading Market Cycles

Home Page together with Index

.

Info!! Altitude Trading Technique Posts

During most of the writing of the blog, I was also engaged inwards my ain trading as well as institute several tools as well as techniques to live on useful.  Below are links to posts I wrote virtually these methods.  If you're interested inwards trading psychology posts, you'll run across relevant links on the Forbes page. 

If y'all can't uncovering the theme you're looking for, y'all mightiness endeavour Googling "" as well as the topic.  That volition frequently clitoris upwardly a few posts, which therefore link to related posts.
  

TOP TRADING TECHNIQUE POSTS:

*  Many Early Posts on Indicators Can Be Found Here

*  This early on site also contains articles on trading methods; run across these articles every bit well

*  Using the NYSE TICK

*  Understanding Market Volume

*  Unique Tools for Processing Market Information

*  Understanding Stock Market Breadth

*  Using Upticks/Downticks for the Dow Stocks

*  Using Relative Volume to Identify Short-Term Opportunities

*  Using Relative Volume to Trade as well as Fade the Market

*  Tracking Instantaneous Demand as well as Supply inwards the Market

*  Tracking Multi-Day Supply as well as Demand

*  Using Breadth to Track Market Strength/Weakness

*  Gauging Market Strength With VWAP

*  Evaluating the Market With Intraday New Highs as well as Lows

*  Why Relative Volume is Important

*  The Importance of Volume inwards the Market

*  Tracking the Market With U.S.A. TICK

*  Using Indicators to Question Strong as well as Weak Markets

*  Identifying Trend Days With Intraday New Highs as well as Lows

*  Catching Trend Days inwards the Market

*  Four Keys to an Upside Trend Day

*  More on Upside Trend Days

*  Identifying Downside Trend Days

*  More on Downside Trend Days

*  Reading Market Cycles

*  Trading Market Cycles

*  Sector Correlation inwards the Stock Market

*  Vol of Vol as well as Trading

*  Time as well as Trading Psychology

*  Tracking Markets inwards Event Time

*  Understanding Markets inwards Event Time

*  Adapting to the Market's True Clock

*  Sites Useful inwards Preparing for Trading

BACK TO THE TRADERFEED HOME PAGE

.

Info!! Finding Chance Inwards Stock Marketplace Pose Cycles

The recent post suggested that a diverseness of marketplace seat observations tin displace live on pulled together past times drawing upon an explanatory framework.  Influenza A virus subtype H5N1 proficient theory non alone helps us empathize what has happened inwards markets; it too suggests what nosotros mightiness notice inwards the future.  Science begins with observation.  Until nosotros link our observations too brand feel of them, they stay isolated information points.  Theory is a large business office of what transforms information into explanation.

What my observations advise is that a express release of variables, such every bit buying too selling pressure; volatility; breadth; sentiment; too correlation, uniquely predict short-term cost receive inwards the stock market.  An ongoing query involvement has focused on the construction of cycles inwards the stock market too the co-movement of these variables at unlike phases of marketplace seat cycles.  In general, I reveal that marketplace seat cycles tin displace live on broken downward into several phases:

1)  Bottoming process - At marketplace seat lows, nosotros tend to consider an elevation of book too volatility too a high flat of marketplace seat correlation, every bit stocks are dumped across the board.  Selling clit per unit of measurement area far exceeds buying clit per unit of measurement area too persuasion becomes quite bearish.  At of import marketplace seat bottoms, nosotros consider cost lows that are non confirmed past times marketplace seat breadth, every bit stiff stocks laid out to diverge from the pack too attract buying interest.  At those bottoms, nosotros too reveal a ascent inwards buying clit per unit of measurement area too a reduction of selling pressure, every bit fresh marketplace seat lows neglect to attract novel selling interest.  

2)  Market rise - With the drying upwards of selling, depression prices attract buying from longer timeframe participants every bit good every bit shorter-term opportunistic ones.  The marketplace seat rises on stiff buying clit per unit of measurement area too depression selling pressure, too the ascent generates sufficient thrust to generate a proficient grade of upside momentum.  Volatility too correlation stay relatively high during the initial elevator off from the lows too breadth is strong.  Dips are bought too the ascent is sustained.

3)  Topping process - The marketplace seat hits a momentum peak, oftentimes identifiable past times a peak inwards the release of shares registering fresh highs.  Selling from this peak to a greater extent than oftentimes than non exceeds the flat of selling seen during the marketplace seat rise, but ultimately attracts buyers.  Weak stocks laid out to diverge from the pack too fresh cost highs typically occur with breadth divergences too lower levels of correlation.  New buying lacks the thrust of the before displace from the lows too volatility wanes.  By the fourth dimension nosotros hitting a cost peak for the cycle, divergences are clear, volatility is low, both buying clit per unit of measurement area too selling clit per unit of measurement area are low, too persuasion remains bullish.  

4)  Market decline - Fresh selling creates a pickup inwards correlation too volatility, every bit short-term back upwards levels are violated too selling clit per unit of measurement area exceeds buying pressure.  Breadth turns negative too the volume of stocks directly displace lower.

The thorniest occupation I accept encountered inwards my run with markets concerns the timing relationships with these phases of marketplace seat cycles.  I am convinced that the cycles are aperiodic (they create non adhere to stiff timetables; in that location is no invariant x-day cycle), too I am too convinced that in that location is a non-random proportionality with the phases that occurs inside too across fourth dimension frames.  Capturing this proportionality has been the greatest challenge inwards the research.

The nesting of larger too smaller cycles creates periods of apparent trending too periods of apparent range-boundedness inwards markets.  Optimal trading strategies conform to the parameters of the cycles operating inwards markets at a given time.  Problems occur inwards trading when a trader's belongings menstruum greatly differs from the operative cycle period(s).  Influenza A virus subtype H5N1 mutual occupation inwards trading today's stock marketplace seat is that the operative cycles are much longer than well-nigh active traders' fourth dimension horizons.  This leads to chasing nickles inwards forepart of larger displace steamrollers. 

By tracking the ongoing changes inwards marketplace seat sentiment, volatility, breadth, correlation, too buying/selling pressure, nosotros tin displace seat where nosotros stand upwards inwards a marketplace seat cycle too accommodate trading strategies accordingly.  During marketplace seat rises too declines, nosotros desire to live on belongings positions too going with momentum; during topping too bottoming processes, nosotros desire to live on fading attain extremes too trading to a greater extent than tactically.  In general, nosotros desire to live on aligned with the largest operative cycles, every bit these greatly comport on the shape too timing of smaller cycles.

I am mindful that it is tardily to reveal "cycles" inwards hindsight, with trivial explanatory benefit.  The cycle concept alone has value insofar every bit it organizes observations with fundamental marketplace seat variables too suggests observations to come.  I volition live on elaborating the explanatory too predictive value of cycles inwards futurity posts; it is the major focus of my marketplace seat research.  For an fantabulous illustration of cycle query creating profitable trading strategies, banking company check out the StockSpotter site.

Further Reading:  Market Profile every bit a Practical Theory
.

Info!! What I've Learned From My Trading Setbacks

During the summertime months, I conduct maintain made a concerted endeavour to operate on my trading.  My twelvemonth to appointment results had been good below my average returns in addition to indeed had turned negative for the possess fourth dimension inwards recent memory.  I took that every bit a worthy challenge in addition to engaged inwards a detailed review of what was working in addition to what wasn't working inwards my trading.  I'm pleased to tell that the results of this operate conduct maintain been quite positive, non only turning the P/L roughly but also instilling both a consistency of procedure in addition to a consistency of results.  Below I portion a few of the things I conduct maintain learned inwards my trading that mightiness hold out of assist to other traders who are adapting to challenging, depression volatility markets:

1)  Think inwards Cycles - This has been ane of the 2 greatest changes I've made inwards my trading.  I stopped thinking nigh trends in addition to ranges entirely, I don't focus on nautical chart patterns, in addition to I don't pretend to know what the "big players" are doing apart from noting book patterns.  Instead, I am identifying dominant cycles inwards the marketplace position at short, medium, in addition to longer fourth dimension frame in addition to focusing on how those cycles interact amongst ane another.  I am focusing on cycles of volatility inwards the market, every bit good every bit cyclical cost action.  This has been a much to a greater extent than effective agency to participate inwards directional marketplace position behavior, specially when implemented inwards trial time. The cycle framework has naturally made me to a greater extent than flexible every bit a trader:  at for certain junctures inwards a cycle, I am a "trend" trader, next the momentum that occurs when cycles employment up.  At other cycle junctures, I am a "mean reversion" trader, adjusting to the "choppiness" that occurs when cycles are non aligned.  Most of all, I've acquire ameliorate at focusing on dominant cycles in addition to the ways inwards which volatility regimes shift the cycles that dominate.

2)  Focus on Execution - H5N1 side produce goodness of the cycle framework is that it allows for simultaneous tracking of brusque term in addition to longer term cycles.  The brusque term cycles acquire extremely useful inwards entry in addition to locomote out execution, allowing the trader to extract to a greater extent than from each trade.  I honour that the divergence betwixt skilful entries in addition to exits in addition to misfortunate ones inwards depression volatility markets is an of import cistron of making in addition to losing money.  I mightiness hold out trading a longer term cycle, but I volition purpose a brusque term cycle to brand it nigh a trough in addition to locomote out nigh a peak.  This is a flake counterintuitive, every bit you're buying when things expect worst in addition to selling when they've been latterly strong.  By giving execution a brusque volatility bias, it's helped me participate inwards directional moves that produce occur.

3)  Focus on Trading Spirituality, Not Just Trading Psychology - This is subtle in addition to is a theme non everyone is comfortable with.  Trading simply doesn't operate when it is *me* focused.  Me making money, me losing, me becoming successful, me working on my the world of mind, etc.  Once the ego is the focus, nosotros lose flexibility in addition to perspective.  I of all people should know that: every bit a psychologist, if therapy ever becomes nigh me, I lose my effectiveness.  The science of a therapist is inwards listening, understanding, in addition to responding to some other person.  If I'm concerned nigh my income, my reputation, or my feelings nigh the other person, I lose my focus in addition to my impact.  In the by months, I've regrounded myself inwards my religious belief in addition to made spiritual readings a daily business office of my forenoon routine. The alter inwards perspective has been dramatic. H5N1 turning betoken occurred when my inquiry yielded a really skilful merchandise opportunity.  I didn't experience excitement, conviction, greed, or whatever of those things.  I felt grateful.  It's a large change.

I'll hold out doing a costless online workshop this calendar week in addition to volition hold out happy to amplify these ideas.  Setbacks occur for a reason; they betoken the agency to novel directions nosotros require to take.  I promise you lot ever conduct maintain setbacks inwards your trading in addition to I promise they ever brand you lot a ameliorate trader--and a ameliorate person.
.

Info!! An Introduction To Trading: Cycles In Addition To Their Implications

In the terminal postal service inward this series, nosotros took a await at the construction of cost changes inward the stock market. The primal thought was that the wide indexes movement inward aperiodic cycles, alongside periods of upward together with downward trending punctuated alongside periods of distribution. With this notion of cyclical construction every bit business office of a conceptual framework for trading, it is possible to generate ideas of probable marketplace activity based upon: 1) where nosotros are at inward the electrical current marketplace cycle together with 2) where the electrical current cycle is situated inside cycles at longer fourth dimension frames. As nosotros movement frontwards inward this e-book, I'll last providing specific examples of cyclical structures, therefore that it volition last easier for y'all to recognize them every bit they are occurring.

This sentiment of marketplace demeanor carries a expose of implications together with helps explicate several mutual marketplace observations:

1) Chart Patterns Make Sense - The literature of technical analysis emphasizes such nautical chart formations every bit double tops together with bottoms, caput together with shoulders formations, cups-and-handles, etc. All of these naturally follow from a cyclical sentiment of markets inward which momentum peaks together with valleys tend to precede cost peaks together with valleys. Similarly, the technical literature is replete alongside oscillators together with ideas virtually trading divergences inward overbought/oversold; RSI; stochastics; MACD; etc. These divergences also brand sense inside a cyclical sentiment of cost change, every bit markets lose momentum prior to reversing. Even the formulations of Elliott together with Gann theorists brand sense every bit ways of conceptualizing phases of momentum inside cyclical patterns.

2) No One Strategy Always Wins - Go dorsum to the idealized nautical chart of cyclical cost modify from the prior post. During the marketplace moves betwixt cost lows together with momentum highs together with betwixt cost highs together with momentum lows, tendency next strategies volition tend to work. During periods betwixt momentum highs together with cost highs together with betwixt momentum lows together with cost lows, nosotros volition tend to run across countertrend (reversal) strategies working. During the flow betwixt cost highs together with momentum lows, we'll tend to run across volatility expand; during the flow betwixt momentum highs together with cost highs, we'll tend to run across volatility dry out up. Using the same strategy across all phases of marketplace cycles volition lawsuit inward periods of uneven performance.

3) No Two Cycles Are Identical - Cycles are nested inside cycles; every bit a rule, the larger the fourth dimension frame, the larger the aAmplitude of the cycle. Thus, markets volition tend to movement to a greater extent than (i.e., display greater cost variability) over a monthly fourth dimension frame than over a daily one. Because larger fourth dimension frames exert influences on shorter ones together with multiple fourth dimension frames are nested, no 1 cycle is identical to others. Traders looking for precise patterns or timing rules to recur are apt to human face upward disappointment. The destination of the trader should last to endeavor to *identify* cycles that we're inward together with frame feasible hypotheses from this identification. That is real dissimilar than trying to predict precise cost activity from a given cyclical formulation. Once again, I'll last providing examples of this every bit nosotros movement along.

4) Trade Execution together with Management - An agreement of cycles volition assist us differentiate the generation of merchandise ideas (which occurs at 1 cycle level) together with the execution together with administration of that merchandise (which occurs at 1 fourth dimension frame lower). This is a real of import concept that volition direct function on improving our trading performance.

The value of a conceptual framework is its powerfulness to direct our agreement together with demeanor together with organize our observations inward meaningful ways. Psychoanalysis is 1 framework for agreement people; behaviorism is another. Buddhism is 1 framework for spiritual life; Judaism is another. Influenza A virus subtype H5N1 useful framework is 1 that speaks to y'all together with that y'all tin genuinely apply inward constructive ways. In this course, we'll last edifice 1 framework that has made sense to me over 30+ years of trading. Your project is to reckon it, detect what--if anything--speaks to you, together with and therefore integrate that data into your ain sense together with understanding.

The destination of this "Introduction to Trading" is to brand y'all your ain guru; to assist y'all sharpen your ain views together with understandings of markets. The thought is non to follow me, precisely to Pb yourself. My project is to offering a few tools that powerfulness last useful inward that process.
.

The Introduction to Trading e-book is a function inward progress; it's beingness written 1 weblog postal service at a time. The updated contents of the mass tin last institute here.

Info!! Marketplace Efficiency Too Trading Amongst Marketplace Cycles

Above is a existent fourth dimension screenshot of the ES futures, amongst 15-minute bars.  It's a squeamish chart, because it illustrates an of import trading principle:  that of the efficiency as well as inefficiency of the market's cost behavior.

In an efficient market, a given total of buying or selling action yields a meaning grade of cost change.  In an inefficient market, a given total of buying or selling action leads to relatively niggling cost change.  

Think of an idealized marketplace cycle.  At the peaks as well as troughs, nosotros accept topping as well as bottoming activity.  Notice, for instance, the bottoming of the ES marketplace at the left mitt side of the nautical chart as well as the topping on the right.  At marketplace turning points, nosotros accept selling as well as buying activity, simply directly that selling as well as buying finds involvement on the other side.  That leads to back-and-forth displace that comprises the bottoming or topping of the cycle.

Between these bottoming as well as topping processes, nosotros come across rather efficient marketplace behavior.  The buying inwards the middle of the nautical chart moves prices relatively steadily higher.  These wheel dynamics last on across multiple fourth dimension frames, including intraday equally noted above.  For an illustration over a long fourth dimension horizon, recall well-nigh the SPX marketplace during 2007 as well as early on 2008 (topping) as well as piece of cake 2008 to early on 2009 (bottoming), amongst efficient selling betwixt the 2 as well as efficient buying afterward.

These wheel dynamics assistance to explicate why trading is then challenging.  During those transitional times of topping as well as bottoming (inefficient markets), fading describe as well as weakness volition last equally a strategy.  During the efficient periods, nosotros desire to ride trends.  If nosotros sympathise wheel dynamics as well as tin assess the transitions betwixt greater as well as lesser efficiency, we're inwards a stronger seat to suit our trading to the supply/demand province of affairs of the marketplace.

It's when we're locked into a unmarried style of trading, whether it's "mean reversion" or "trending", that nosotros courtroom frustration, equally we're ill-prepared to merchandise amongst marketplace cycles.  As I've noted inwards the past, if we're going to trip the lite fantastic amongst the market, nosotros accept to permit it lead; otherwise, we'll honor ourselves inwards a ballroom waltz when the music turns hip-hop.

Further Reading:  The Dynamics of Stock Market Cycles
.

Info!! How Linguistic Communication Defines Our Limits--And Our Opportunities

Many trading challenges are embedded inwards the linguistic communication nosotros utilization to depict markets.

Among the around mutual things I withdraw heed from traders is that markets are hard to merchandise because they are "choppy" in addition to "noisy".  What, precisely, does this mean?

A clue to the pregnant is that nosotros never withdraw heed the opposite.  When was the concluding fourth dimension y'all e'er observed a trader high-fiving because markets were "smooth" in addition to "predictable"?  When receive got y'all heard person making coin attribute profits to marketplace "noise"?

Yet or in addition to thus other clue to the pregnant is that really few traders truly mensurate marketplace choppiness/noise.  It's non that racket in addition to dot are role of an explicit trading framework; rather choppiness is used equally a argue to either explicate losses or to non merchandise at all.  From that perspective, a choppy marketplace is 1 that cannot move successfully traded.  It's the marketplace equivalent of playing inwards a casino where the game is severely rigged against the gambler.  Perhaps that is why in addition to thus many conversations that firstly on the theme of marketplace chop veer onto the theme of "algos" in addition to their "manipulation" of markets.

As Wittgenstein observes, linguistic communication captures our limits in addition to our possibilities.  If our linguistic communication describes people of a sure enough race or ethnicity equally inferior people, nosotros volition sustain all sorts of behavioral biases against those people.  If nosotros experience a require to merchandise to brand a living in addition to our linguistic communication construes markets equally impossibly noisy, frustration is the inevitable result.  The trader who bemoans choppy markets is truly conveying the meaning, "I reveal this marketplace untradable in addition to frustrating".

The occupation amongst such linguistic communication is that it leads to no possible solution.  If I reckon a cast of people equally worthless, I receive got basically blocked whatsoever potential positive interactions.  If I persuasion markets equally filled amongst noise, I block whatsoever efforts to seat signal.

The traders I run across making coin are employing linguistic communication differently to brand sense of frequently-changing markets.  For example, several traders I know are trading shorter-term strategies in addition to longer-term strategies in addition to adjusting the weighting of those based upon how markets are moving.  Influenza A virus subtype H5N1 skillful illustration was yesterday's merchandise inwards the ES futures.  We had early on selling off the weak jobs number, but many sectors of the marketplace displayed buying interest.  The advance-decline line was unusually strong, given the turn down inwards the average, in addition to nosotros never striking a selling extreme of -800 or less inwards the NYSE TICK measure.  This was a useful nation that the selling was role of sector rotation, non role of a full general bear/risk-off move.  Recognizing this made it much easier to receive got profits on brusk positions early on inwards the hateful solar daytime in addition to non larn whipsawed past times the afternoon strength.

A to a greater extent than radical linguistic communication shift is to break markets downward into cycles in addition to trends in addition to seat when each style is dominant.  This leads to hateful reverting trades inwards cyclical regimes in addition to momentum trades inwards trending ones.  Note hither the conceptual shift: noisy markets are defined equally cyclical ones.  That leads to a potentially constructive direction: identifying whether at that topographic point is a dominant wheel that tin move expected to give-up the ghost on into the immediate future.  An adaptive trader trades the marketplace weather condition that exist, non whatsoever preferred authorities across the board.

My ain trading has proceeded amongst a however to a greater extent than radical shift.  I firstly amongst the thought that *only* cycles be inwards fiscal markets.  What appear equally momentum/trend in addition to value/mean reverting periods are only unlike phases of cycles that be at varying frequencies.  It is the interplay of these longer in addition to shorter duration cycles that creates the complexity of displace inside markets.  When cycles at shorter in addition to longer frequencies are inwards hateful reverting style concurrently, markets volition facial expression choppy.  When multiple cycles are aligned inwards upwardly or downward phases, markets volition facial expression trending.  It's all 1 elephant in addition to we're the blind men feeling diverse parts of the brute in addition to trying to figure out what it looks like.

A natural resultant of adopting the linguistic communication of cycles is that it naturally leads to an mental attitude of "this likewise shall pass."  Indeed, if nosotros retrieve of multiple cycles aligning inwards a mean-reverting mode, that suggests that multiple cycles may move peaking or cresting.  In such a case, the periods of greatest choppiness would tend to precede the periods of greatest opportunity.

Language frames our problems in addition to linguistic communication frames our chance set.  I strongly suspect at that topographic point are no markets devoid of opportunity; alone impoverished mindsets.

Further Reading:  The Dynamics of Market Cycles
.

Info!! Trading Marketplace Cycles

In the previous post, I proposed a system for reading marketplace cycles, past times breaking those cycles into phases based upon marketplace activity.  Trading marketplace cycles requires a sort of creative opportunism described past times Gehry.  The materials on the tabular array are characteristics of marketplace behavior.  When trading well, nosotros are arranging those inward a fashion that enables us to capture corporation reward-to-risk relationships.

A cycle-based site for stock in addition to ETF trading that quantifies marketplace cycles in addition to makes purchase in addition to sell recommendations is StockSpotter.  The site makes many recommendations--more than the average trader would accept inward a day.  So they copy functioning past times taking rattling many random groups of 4 recommendations (Monte Carlo simulation) to demo the hit of probable trading outcomes from next those picks.  It's i of the to a greater extent than elegant demonstrations of border that I've seen from a marketplace service.  The opportunism comes when nosotros accept other criteria for buying or selling, such every bit our substitution analysis of a companionship or our sentiment of the entire market, in addition to espouse those to the site's recommendations.  What we're trying to exercise amongst this sort of opportunism is bring together 2 or to a greater extent than independent sources of edge, thence every bit to maximize the probability of success.

A dissimilar sort of opportunism powerfulness await at split overbought/oversold measures on 2 or to a greater extent than dissimilar fourth dimension frames.  For example, I'll await at the upticks/downticks inward the marketplace every bit a rattling short-term mensurate of overbought/oversold in addition to an oscillator of cost alter to capture a medium fourth dimension frame.  When nosotros are topping in addition to dropping, we'll run across the measures peak at equal or successively lower cost levels: the buyers nonetheless movement the market, only cannot movement it higher over time.  When nosotros are bottoming in addition to rising, we'll run across the measures trough at equal or successively higher cost levels.  In opportunistically aligning the fourth dimension frames in addition to marketplace behavior, nosotros tin detect corporation risk/reward ways to exploit marketplace cycles.

Still approximately other cast of opportunism for daytraders involves tracking gild flow--seeing when bids or offers are asset detail levels--and joining that data to a broader sentiment on trend/direction.  For instance, if nosotros run across recurring bids beingness hitting at a given cost degree where that degree holds, nosotros powerfulness bring together the offering if nosotros run across that the bigger painting demo for the stock is higher.  

It is this lining upward of marketplace deportment that creates approximately of the best trades.  Waiting for the lining upward requires patience in addition to perspective.  H5N1 keen bargain of productive trading fourth dimension is spent non trading, only actively watching for those occasions when i beginning of border falls into house amongst another--and thence pouncing on those opportunities amongst meaningful risk-taking.

Further Reading:  Some Great Rules for Life in addition to Trading
.

Info!! Getting By The Frustration Of Trading Choppy Markets

When nosotros accept difficulty arriving at solutions, many times it's because nosotros haven't spent sufficient fourth dimension defining the relevant problem.

Trading major U.S.A. stock indexes the past times several months has been quite interesting, equally we've traded inside a arrive at throughout that time.  Several sectors--most notably commodity-related shares--have been unusually weak; several sectors (consumer discretionary, healthcare) accept been relatively strong.  Altogether the major indexes accept gone nowhere, though they've traveled a considerable distance inside their range.  That's the really Definition of a low-Sharpe asset.

It's non odd to hear traders lament such "choppy" markets.  What they're genuinely proverb is that the marketplace position isn't sustaining directional displace over intended belongings periods.  The trader wants to net income from a displace from X to Y inward Z fourth dimension period, but the marketplace position volition displace from X to X' in addition to opposite to X or beyond earlier it e'er gets to Y inward the Z period.  For the trader hoping to innovation a merchandise amongst expert risk/reward--a cost target twice equally far away equally their stop-out grade (or more)--such choppiness leads to frustration.  An intended 2:1 reward-to-risk merchandise isn't thus favorable when you're stopped out 3 times equally oft equally you lot hitting the target! 

Hence the lament:  choppy markets precisely aren't tradeable.

Been there, done that:  this calendar week lonely I had several intraday trades inward ES that moved 4-5 points inward my favor earlier retracing in addition to moving against me.  Frustrating.

That led me to pass to a greater extent than fourth dimension defining the problem.  

Suppose nosotros model whatever marketplace position fourth dimension serial equally the amount of a linear (trend) ingredient in addition to ane or to a greater extent than cyclical components.  (John Ehlers' work is a expert representative of this sort of thinking).  To the extent that at that spot is footling cyclical ingredient in addition to a dominant linear component, nosotros accept a consistently trending marketplace position where buy/sell in addition to concur would live on an ideal strategy.  To the extent that at that spot is footling linear ingredient in addition to a dominant cyclical component, nosotros accept a consistently oscillating, mean-reverting market, where fading overbought in addition to oversold levels would live on an ideal strategy.

Of course, the fiscal globe is a fleck to a greater extent than complex than that, equally linear components tin vary inward their gradient in addition to cyclical components tin vary inward both frequency in addition to amplitude.  The relative residuum betwixt linear in addition to cyclical components changes over time, equally create slope, frequency, in addition to amplitude.  This way that whatever unmarried approach to trading markets--trend following, counter-trend trading--will become through winning in addition to losing periods simply equally a business office of changing cycles.

So allow us define choppy markets equally ones amongst depression linear ingredient in addition to cyclical components amongst high frequency in addition to depression amplitude.  That would define a depression VIX marketplace position (low amplitude) amongst minimal persistence of directional movement.

Such a marketplace position is untradeable solely if you lot involve to merchandise directional trends of a certainly size in addition to duration.  Consider:  within each cycle, at that spot are linear/directional components; these merely terminal for less fourth dimension in addition to move less distance when the cycles are higher inward frequency in addition to lower inward amplitude.  If you lot were to model those cycles, however, you lot would uncovering that, for whatever stable marketplace position period, directional moves of X tin live on expected for belongings periods of one-half the dominant bike frequency.

Traders frustrated past times choppy markets mightiness plow to psychoanalysis, but bike analysis is belike to a greater extent than relevant in addition to helpful.  I modeled the recent marketplace position linear in addition to cyclical components later my frustrating trades (hint: cycles are clearer when you lot don't purpose fourth dimension equally your X-axis) and, certainly enough, I flora that the odds of hitting my cost targets given the electrical flow authorities were genuinely quite low.  Influenza A virus subtype H5N1 displace of four ES points was expectable inward my intended belongings period; a displace of viii points was unlikely.

A mutual slice of marketplace position wisdom is that traders must merchandise inward a way that is consistent amongst their personalities.  There is truth to that--a quantitative investor belike volition non create good equally a discretionary hateful solar daytime trader--but all also oft that regulation is used to justify sticking amongst trading methods that merely create non check marketplace position conditions.  No ane would tell an possessor of commercial radio stations to programme the airwaves to check his or her personality.  Rather, programming would involve to check the marketplace of targeted listeners.  Similarly, traders involve to suit to *their* marketplace--and in addition to thus re-adapt equally that marketplace evolves.

Perhaps the occupation is non choppy markets, but static traders.  When all nosotros accept is a hammer, Maslow noted, nosotros inevitably process everything equally nails.

Further Reading:  Understanding Market Cycles

.

Info!! Using Cycles To Merchandise Marketplace Trends

Even inwards trending markets, nosotros meet cyclical behavior.  In a distinct uptrend, nosotros volition brand cycle lows at successively higher toll levels.  In a downtrend, nosotros brand cycle highs at successively lower toll levels.  Those cyclical movements tin post away furnish worthwhile entry areas for those looking to ride longer-term trends.  In other words, nosotros tin post away participate inwards a trending marketplace past times going amongst the tendency for our merchandise but entering countertrend amongst the marketplace cycles.  This is unlike from momentum trading, where we're looking to purchase forcefulness together with sell weakness on toll breakouts.  In a depression volatility environment, using momentum to fourth dimension entries tin post away Pb to getting chopped up.  

The nautical chart higher upwards depicts cyclical demeanour inwards SPY (blue line) equally a component of a moving average of the percentages of stocks inwards the index trading higher upwards diverse moving averages (data from Index Indicators).  You tin post away meet we're inwards oversold territory on the mensurate at a higher toll low.  This leads me to await at to the lowest degree a retest of recent highs inwards the market's bigger picture.  Very proficient short-term trades tin post away endure flora when intraday flows trouble upwards amongst this larger marketplace picture.

This is soundless simply about other means that nosotros tin post away integrate quantitative together with discretionary information inwards our trading.

Further Reading:   Trading Market Cycles
.

Info!! Going Dorsum To Schoolhouse For Your Trading

Well, it's a snowy Sabbatum inwards Mia as well as I are listening to love songs as well as going dorsum to school.  There's no meliorate formula for a total life than to alive meaningfully as well as larn constantly.  That way, you're ever growing: inwards your pump as well as inwards your head.

Going dorsum to schoolhouse is an practise I furnish to periodically that keeps me fresh as a trader.  It's actually a furnish to the procedure past times which I learned trading.  For good over a year, at the halt of the twenty-four hours I printed out charts of the marketplace (price/volume) as well as charts of every indicator that I believed could stimulate got value inwards anticipating marketplace moves.  I knew that, for whatsoever express catamenia of time, indicators could randomly appear to stimulate got value.  Over the course of pedagogy of weeks as well as months, however, patterns recurred that helped me focus on the measures that added truthful value.  It was through those initial explorations that I discovered trading patterns inwards NYSE TICK (upticks/downticks amidst all NYSE stocks) as well as breadth divergences.  Those remain staples of how I await at markets to this day.

When I returned to trading after a 5 yr hiatus during which I worked total fourth dimension at a hedge fund as well as was non allowed to merchandise for compliance reasons, 1 of my get-go steps was to acquire dorsum to school.  I observed novel patterns, including the relationships amidst macro markets as well as how movements inwards currencies, rates, as well as commodities were related to moves inwards stocks.  Carefully reviewing marketplace demeanor infinitesimal past times minute, twenty-four hours past times day, gave me a fresh appreciation of book as well as volatility as well as the ways inwards which large institutional participants assist to deed the market.  This led to novel ways of viewing the uptick/downtick as well as breadth data, as good as novel ways to stair out buying as well as selling pressure level to hold upwards on the correct side of the marketplace movers.

Still later, I felt my trading results were non what they should be.  Specifically, I became disenchanted amongst my quantitative models as well as looked at why they occasionally broke down.  I began focusing on the inquiry of whether cycles be inwards the marketplace as well as whether those could assist the identification of relative highs as well as lows.  Once again, I made a twenty-four hours to twenty-four hours study, infinitesimal past times minute, as well as returned to school.  What I constitute was that measurement cycles inwards chronological fourth dimension was non peculiarly effective.  More properly, I constitute that cycles are meliorate identified inwards event time than chronological time.  That led to novel ways of measurement overbought as well as oversold markets, as good as new ways of assessing volatility.    

So straight off it's dorsum to school.  I'm reviewing recent markets as well as the close meaningful recurring patterns among  the measures I track.  What I'm finding is that I follow a lot of things that ultimately are non crucial to decision-making.  I could hold upwards much to a greater extent than efficient past times tracking a to a greater extent than express ready of unique data.  I'm likewise finding existent value inwards looking at how shorter-term cycles are nested inside longer-term ones; i.e., viewing cycles inwards context.  This was peculiarly helpful inwards identifying the marketplace plough this week.

There are 3 of import lessons inwards all this:

1)  In getting dorsum to schoolhouse as well as looking at markets through fresh eyes, nosotros tin suit to changing markets as well as nosotros tin continuously grow as traders. If you lot precisely stimulate got a passion for trading, you'll overtrade.  It's a passion to empathize as well as original markets that tin drib dead along you lot going through the ups as well as downs of your equity curve.

2)  None of the close of import information that shows upwards inwards my reviews is a traditional technical marketplace measure, such as a nautical chart blueprint or canned oscillator.  None.  The value is inwards novel information as well as novel ways of organizing the data.  If you're tracking the information other people are tracking as well as if you're assembling the information the means others are, you're precisely non going to accomplish distinctive returns;

3)  The best means to improve your trading psychology is to improve your trading.  People promise they'll merchandise meliorate if they improve their mindset, command their emotions, etc.  All that tin hold upwards useful, but cannot substitute for genuine insight as well as information.  When you lot become dorsum to school, you lot cement your ain learning.  That is what gives us the confidence to stimulate got adventure as well as remain amongst trades when the odds are amongst us.  

OK, Mia as well as I are finishing the end song as well as heading to the basement.  That's where the practise room is located as well as where nosotros occur trunk after working on mind.  That's a unlike school, but 1 that is as important. 

Keep growing.

In all respects.

Further Reading:  Learning From Our Trading
.

Info!! Lessons Inward Trading As Well As Psychology - 5: Cycles

Many times, traders give-up the ghost frustrated as well as autumn into a negative psychology because they are looking for 1 thing, spell the marketplace is doing something else.  In that sense, frustration gives us information: that nosotros are perhaps out of sync alongside what nosotros are trading.

Above nosotros run across the S&P futures (blue line) plotted from Feb twelfth through Friday's unopen (February 16th).  If nosotros were to exercise a regression job to best lucifer this action, nosotros would run across a job alongside a decent lucifer as well as a positive slope.  That tells us at that topographic point is a tendency gene to how the marketplace is trading over that fourth dimension horizon.

Notice, however, the tendency is far from a smoothen upward line.  The ruby-red job captures a dominant bicycle inside the trend, where a 50-bar charge per unit of measurement of modify is expressed inward touchstone departure units (left axis).  Each bar captures displace inward number time, non chronological time.  In this chart, each bar is drawn when the futures convey changed cost 500 times.  

The number fourth dimension bars adjust our fourth dimension serial for the volatility of the market's cost action.  When nosotros convey depression volatility, nosotros describe fewer bars as well as vice versa.  Standardizing the marketplace thought this means provides us alongside a to a greater extent than stable fourth dimension series, as well as that helps us improve assess cycles inside the market.  Those cycles nation us when nosotros are relatively overbought or oversold.

In an upward trend, buying the marketplace when nosotros approach a two touchstone departure bicycle trough ends upwards providing pretty skilful entry.  Indeed, nosotros tin define a tendency yesteryear the presence of bicycle troughs/peaks at successively higher/lower cost levels.  Notice besides how the frequency of the dominant bicycle gives us a window on how "choppy" the marketplace may be--and how changes inward the frequency plough over us a clue equally to whether a tendency is waxing or waning.

Stocks or instruments displaying greater clarity/consistency of trends as well as cycles powerfulness survive the best trading vehicles for a trader.

Looking at cost behaviour inward novel ways opens novel trading possibilities--and that tin expand our psychology, fueling our agreement as well as feel of mastery.

Further Reading:

Adapting to the Market's True Clock

Home Page as well as Index

.

Info!! Trading Notes For The Calendar Week Of April 25, 2016

Friday, Apr 29th

*  I'll hold upwards talking amongst the Benzinga pre-market prep show at 8:35 AM today.  We'll create got a seem at the psychology of the electrical current market.

*  I beloved this postal service regarding innovating too finding novel merchandise setups from Ivanhoff.

*  Stocks bounced nicely from overnight weakness yesterday but too then stalled at prior peak levels too sold off sharply into the close.  Breadth was non peculiarly poor; fresh monthly novel highs dropped to 915 too novel lows rose a fighting to 235.  Technology/NASDAQ shares broke below their before Apr lows; housing stocks (XHB) also took a hit.  That's non the form of activity you'd await if the marketplace position was pricing inwards economical strength.  Fewer than 50% of SPX shares are trading inwards a higher house their 3, 5, too 10-day moving averages.  Let's encounter if that tin send away convey inwards buyers, equally prior short-term corrections create got been able to do.

*  H5N1 few things dissimilar most this most recent marketplace position drop:  1) higher volatility on the decline, amongst extreme selling on the NYSE TICK measure; 2) the market's inability to rally during USD weakness too commodity firmness; too 3) continued breakdown of correlations amid marketplace position sectors.  It's when nosotros encounter shifts inwards volatility too correlation that nosotros desire to entertain notions of authorities change.

*  My intermediate-term measures are silent nowhere close oversold levels.  I'm quite opened upwards to toppy marketplace position activity hither too an intermediate-term correction inside the bull cycle.  I'm non expecting a precipitous reversal to send marketplace position mode.  Note the precipitous rising inwards VIX.  My Pure VIX model has turned neutral; non yet inwards "fearful" territory.

Thursday, Apr 28th

*  A seem at the recent displace to higher involvement rates, which has affected the trading of higher yielding stocks too stock sectors.

*  Stocks create got fallen dorsum afterward the Bank of Nippon disappointment final night.  We're right away close the lower terminate of the recent trading range.  I haven't noticed item breadth weakness.  Indeed, smaller cap indexes moved to novel highs yesterday, equally did a lay out of large cap sectors.  Much of the index weakness has come upwards from technology scientific discipline shares too the higher yielding sectors.  New monthly highs rose to 1112; novel lows rose a fighting to 209.  My intermediate-term wheel measures are stretched to the upside, however, so I would non hold upwards surprised to encounter farther consolidation.

*  Most of the corrective activity we've seen inwards stocks since the Feb depression has consisted of sector rotation; therefore no meaningful deterioration inwards the breadth numbers.  Below nosotros tin send away encounter a nautical chart of stocks across all the States exchanges making fresh 3-month highs versus 3-month lows.  It has stayed good for yous throughout the recent move.  One of the things I'm tracking going forrad is the grade to which nosotros encounter across the board weakness on pullbacks versus rotational movement. 

Wednesday, Apr 27th

*  Here's a valuable perspective on challenging hedge fund performance from the Mathematical Investor site.

*  My mensurate of breadth volatility has reached depression levels final reached inwards belatedly November, 2015 before the marketplace position drop.  Volume inwards stocks has also been lagging, which has been associated amongst subnormal forrad returns.  That beingness said, breadth improved yesterday, amongst 876 fresh monthly novel highs too 189 novel lows.

*  Note the divergent sector surgery inwards the past times week, amongst higher yielding shares underperforming too commodity-related shares outperforming.  (Graphic from FinViz).  Rates create got been rising ahead of the Fed; I'm keeping a unopen optic on this.  Note also how technology scientific discipline has been lagging.  Rising rates?  Higher commodities?  Low growth?  Can't imagine a stagflation scenario would hold upwards a non bad one...

Tuesday, Apr 26th

*  Excellent interrogation links from Abnormal Returns.  H5N1 non bad aggregation of quant interrogation comes from Quantocracy.  Lots of novel ideas inwards these sources too lots of practiced blogs to follow.

*  So far my trading experiment has been interesting.  I've been placing far fewer trades, solely trading when the marketplace position lines upwards on 3 fourth dimension frames too a short-term signal is triggered.  The signal comes from volatility bands drawn around lawsuit bars, so the bands reverberate what I've been calling pure volatility (volatility per unit of measurement of marketplace position volume).  The target is also based upon a motility inwards pure volatility units.  The really structured nature of the opportunity taking has led to zilch overtrading too a higher hitting charge per unit of measurement on trades.  I'm placing solely a 10th of the trades I was placing before, overall profitability inwards dollar price has non been hurt, too of course of educational activity risk-adjusted profitability has increased greatly.  It is non clear to me that much of the trading nosotros produce adds value.  By structuring rules around our best trades, nosotros tin send away create important gratis fourth dimension for interrogation too life exterior of markets.

*  We saw increased selling push clit per unit of measurement area inwards yesterday's trade, but cost held relatively good too has bounced a fighting inwards overnight trade.  New monthly highs dropped to 586 too monthly lows also dipped to 208.  I'm silent non seeing important weakness across sectors; the key banking company focus the balance of the calendar week volition dominate trade.  

*  We tin send away encounter the market's forcefulness inwards the wheel mensurate below.  My long-term wheel interrogation suggests that nosotros made an of import wheel depression inwards Feb (the prior wheel depression was October, 2014) too create got been inwards a momentum stage of the novel cycle.  I ultimately await the electrical current wheel to create got us to novel highs, driven equally much past times dovish key banks too the postulate for yield equally growth per se.

Monday, Apr 25th

*  There is a psychological procedure that underlies self-confidence--and to a greater extent than specifically a cognitive process.  Key is the recognition is that confidence is an seem of optimism--and optimism comes from finding structural similarities betwixt introduce challenges too past times ones that create got been mastered.  This is really relevant to the capacity to stick amongst one's ideas too atmospheric condition drawdowns.

*  I'm currently working on a projection that tracks long-term cycles inwards the stock market.  These cycles extend for months, non minutes or days.  It is at this horizon that momentum effects most clearly emerge.  For example, if nosotros larn dorsum to 2006 too rails the per centum of SPX shares that unopen inwards a higher house their 100-day moving averages, nosotros notice that the move past times one-half of readings (those inwards which in that location has been strongest breadth) final result inwards an average side past times side 50-day gain of +2.15%.  The bottom one-half of readings average a side past times side 50-day gain of solely +.33%.  The lion's part of the surgery differential occurs afterward a 20-day belongings period.  Think most what that agency for traders who prepare longer-term ideas but create got to merchandise them on curt fourth dimension frames too what that agency for short-term traders.  Also recollect most the implications for the electrical current market.

*  Stocks create got pulled dorsum inwards overnight trading, continuing to consolidate recent gains.  None of my breadth measures propose that we're yet at an oversold level, equally tin send away hold upwards seen below.  This mensurate tracks SPX shares trading inwards a higher house their 3, 5, 10, too 20-day moving averages.  (Raw information from Index Indicators).